WASHINGTON — A federal choose on Tuesday blocked the Trump administration from terminating $14 billion in grants awarded to a few local weather teams by the Biden administration, saying the federal government’s “obscure and unsubstantiated assertions of fraud are inadequate.”
The order by U.S. District Choose Tonya Chutkan prevents — for now — the Environmental Safety Company from ending the grant program, which totaled $20 billion. The choose additionally blocked Citibank, which holds the cash on behalf of EPA, from transferring it to the federal government or anybody else.
EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin accused the grant recipients of mismanagement, fraud and self-dealing and froze the grants. However after reviewing arguments within the case, Chutkan stated Zeldin’s allegations fell brief.
“At this juncture, EPA Defendants haven’t sufficiently defined why unilaterally terminating Plaintiffs’ grant awards was a rational precursor to reviewing” the inexperienced financial institution program, Chutkan wrote.
She was the third choose of the day to rule towards the Trump administration. The trio of rulings got here inside hours of a unprecedented battle, as President Donald Trump referred to as for the impeachment of one other choose who had quickly blocked deportation flights. Trump’s message drew a rare rebuke from Supreme Courtroom Chief Justice John Roberts.
Local weather United Fund and different teams had sued the EPA, Zeldin and Citibank, saying that they had illegally denied the teams entry to $14 billion awarded final 12 months by way of the Greenhouse Gasoline Discount Fund, generally known as a “inexperienced financial institution.” This system was created by the 2022 Inflation Discount Act to finance clear power and climate-friendly tasks.
Local weather United and two different teams, the Coalition for Inexperienced Capital and Energy Ahead Communities, stated the freeze not solely prevented them from financing new tasks, however may drive them to put off employees. They stated the allegations they had been mishandling funds had been completely meritless.
The nonprofits additionally wished Choose Chutkan to order Citibank to unfreeze the account. She declined to take action. The order merely preserves the established order whereas the case proceeds.
Local weather United was awarded practically $7 billion, the Coalition for Inexperienced Capital gained $5 billion and Energy Ahead Communities was awarded $2 billion. Republicans unanimously voted towards the legislation that created the grant program and have denounced it as an unaccountable “slush fund.”
After the funds had been frozen, the EPA moved to terminate the grants.
Local weather United CEO Beth Bafford stated the choose’s determination Tuesday was “a step in the precise path.”
“Within the coming weeks, we’ll proceed working in direction of a long-term resolution that may enable us to put money into tasks that ship power financial savings, create jobs, and increase American manufacturing in communities throughout the nation,” Bafford stated.
Zeldin stated in a press release posted on X Tuesday that the grants had been awarded “in a way that intentionally lowered the flexibility of EPA to conduct correct oversight.”
“I can’t relaxation till these hard-earned taxpayer {dollars} are returned to the U.S. Treasury,” he stated.
Zeldin has characterised the grants as a “gold bar” scheme marred by conflicts of curiosity and potential fraud.
“Twenty billion of your tax {dollars} had been parked at an outdoor monetary establishment, in a deliberate effort to restrict authorities oversight — doling out your cash by way of simply eight pass-through, politically linked, unqualified and in some circumstances brand-new” nonprofit organizations, Zeldin stated in a video beforehand posted on-line.
Local weather United countered that the termination was illegal, arguing the federal authorities had recognized no proof of waste, fraud or abuse.
___
Phillis reported from St. Louis.
